Navigation ...
|
|
|
Scientific Writing ...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Other Writing ...
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reference details
Author(s)
| Year
| Title
| Reference
| View/Download
|
Les Hatton , Greg Warr | 2017a | Reproducibility package: Proteins and Computer Programs: Inextricably linked by Information Theory: | WEB | HattonWarr_PRSB_22-Jan-2017.zip |
Synopsis and invited feedback
Peer review is important and acquiring competent reviewers is becoming a major problem for the journals today so I will be very happy to include constructive comment (positive or negative) with acknowledgement. If I am not competent to judge your commentary I will try and find somebody who is.
If you would like to provide feedback just e-mail me here.
Synopsis
| Invited Feedback
| Importance (/10, author rated :-) )
|
NOTE: The corresponding paper is under review as of January 2017, although this reproducibility package is complete and reproduces all figures, tables and statistical results of that paper. If and when the paper is accepted, the accompanying text will be included with this package.
The paper was rejected. The first reviewer found a mistake (thanks !) which we then corrected. The second reviewer was so anxious to spend their review time criticizing a previously published paper of ours, they failed to read this one properly. Extraordinary unprofessionalism. | The journal concerned requires reproducibility information to be available at the time of submission.
Sadly, they didn't even try to reproduce the results. Who cares about reproducibility anyway ? Its only science. | 10 |
Related links
Related papers and links
|
Sorry, no links registered in database yet. |
Auto-generated: $Revision: 1.63 $, $Date: 2020/01/25 16:18:09 $, Copyright Les Hatton 2001-
|